Just to make sure I’m not seeing or imagining things, as I’ve already told you, the playback of Blu-ray 3D movies may be a bit of an issue on your PC with a 120Hz 3D capable LCD monitor using 3D Vision, because these displays are HDCP compliant only at 60Hz. This means that you need to remove the HDCP protection in order to watch these movies without issues, otherwise here is what you get…
PowerDVD 10 Ultra Mark II may or may not start to play the 3D movie for a few seconds than it may stop either with blank screen or return to a window mode in 2D and display the error message that your display is not HDCP compatible.
Total Media Theatre 3 Platinum + Sim3D plugin also may start to play the 3D video for a few seconds or directly display the above error message regarding the display not being HDCP compliant.
The above two pictures show what you get when trying to play Monsters vs Aliens 3D (sold as a bundle with hardware) and Grand Canyon Adventure (sold separately) Blu-ray 3D movies (original discs) on Samsung 2233RZ monitor with 3D Vision. These are the only two Blu-ray 3D movies that I currently have to test with, but pretty much all 3D movies (if not specifically with removed HDCP protection should behave the same), unless you have something active to remove the HDCP protection in real-time like AnyDVD for example as I’ve already mentioned a few days ago. It is possible that the second generation 120Hz LCD monitors from Alienware, Acer, Asus and LG might not be affected with the HDCP issue like the first generation ones from Samsung and ViewSonic, but currently I cannot confirm that as currently I don’t have any of them to try with.
Tags:3d vision·blu-ray 3d·hdcp·HDCP 3D issues·HDCP issues·PowerDVD 10 Ultra Mark II·Sim3D Plugin·Total Media Theatre 3 Platinum
Cyberlink is going to have the promised Mark-II Update for their PowerDVD 10 software in a few days, at the beginning of July and it is even possible for it to be available as soon as 6st of July. The main focus of the PowerDVD10 Mark-II update is to bring support for playing Blu-ray 3D movies on your computer using 3D Vision or another of the supported viewing methods. The Mark II update will be free for the owners of the PowerDVD 10 Ultra version of the player software as this is the version of PowerDVD that is targeted for users willing to play 3D content from their computer. The PowerDVD 10 also comes with function for converting 2D video to 3D, of course with an end result not as good as with video shot in stereo 3D, but it can still be useful considering the current general lack of video content in 3D. And PowerDVD will also be able to play other 3D video files in Side-by-Side or Above/Under formats pretty soon, but that functionality will come a bit later with another update, so meanwhile you can stick to the 3D Vision Video Player for playing back 3D videos other than Blu-ray 3D movies.
I was able to test the upcoming Blu-ray 3D video playback functionality thanks to CyberLink providing me with a PowerDVD Blu-ray 3D preview version for evaluation, and I can say that it works just great with playing back MVC encoded 3D videos and Blu-ray 3D content. I was able to try the Blu-ray 3D playback using 3D Vision on Samsung 2233RZ 3D LCD monitor and Acer H5360 3D DLP projector and both worked flawlessly with the latest 3D Vision Drivers version 257.21. Other than 3D Vision with supported display, Cyberlink’s PowerDVD 10 software also supports playback of Blu-ray 3D content on normal monitors with the help of plain red-cyan anaglyph glasses, row-interleaved 3D displays and even 3D-capable TVs. Now regarding the 3D HDTV support I need to make some things clear, as this mode will probably not work with all of the latest 3D television sets that are currently appearing on the market at this time, but they might be supported with a future update. This mode is intended to provide DLP checkerboard output of the 3D content that can be display mostly on 3D DLP TVs like the ones made by Mitsubishi, but this mode is also supported by some of the newer 3D HDTVs using HDMI 1.4(a) for stereo 3D support. One such example is the C7000 series of 3D TV’s by Samsung that should work just fine with PowerDVD 10 Blu-ray 3D playback as it supports both row-interleaved input as well as checkerboard pattern. On the other hand the Panasonic VT25 and VT20 3D HDTVs do not support any of those two modes, so you will most likely not be able to play Blu-ray 3D movies with PowerDVD 10 after the release of the Mark II update. But as I already mentioned, support for these 3D TVs will most likely be added at a later time with the help of future updates of both the software video player and
Another thing that I tried with the preview version of PowerDVD I got from Cyberlink was the new and improved 2D-to-3D conversion feature called TrueTheater 3D. If you remember I was not very impressed with what Cyberlink has offered in their trial version of PowerDVD 10 when it was first made available in terms of 2D to 3D video conversion. I simply expected more and Cyberlink has managed to get more done with their new conversion algorithm that provided better and more comfortable conversion for videos to 3D. Have in mind that the currently available trial version of PowerDVD 10 still uses the first generation of 2D to 3D conversion, but the people who purchased the full software and have updated it to version 10.0.1714 and later should already have the next generation of 2D to 3D conversion functionality available. What I’ve noticed at first is that the new algorithm is no longer using the frame offsetting to create the Pulfrich kind of effect based on the movement of objects in the frames next to each other. And that means that even in very fast switching scenes or movement the effect will not be a somewhat disturbing anymore because even for a brief moment you will not be seeing two completely different images from different scenes with each eye. So job well done on that too for Cyberlink.
And to be completely fair, I should also mention that I’ve contacted ArcSoft about an evaluation version of their Sim 3D plugin for TotalMedia Theatre 3 Platinum. They are already selling this plugin along with the TMT3 Platinum software – their two components that allow you to play Blu-ray 3D movies, but they did not even reply to me. So as a result there is no comparison between the TotalMedia Theatre 3 Platinum + Sim 3D plugin and PowerDVD10’s 3D capabilities. And since I’m quite satisfied from what I saw from PowerDVD and there is no other way to test ArcSoft’s solution other than paying $89.99 for the TotalMedia Theatre 3 Platinum software and another $19.99 for the Sim3D Plugin (total $109,98 USD) I would prefer to stick to PowerDVD 10 Ultra with the Mark II update that currently costs $89.95 USD ($71.95 if you are upgrading from PowerDVD 8, 9 or 10 Standard).
Now we just need more high-quality stereo 3D content available, as still we have only one Blu-ray 3D movie that just recently became available as a standalone product (not bundled with any 3D-capable hardware) is Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs. But more movies should be coming very soon, so stay tuned for more information about that as well as more information about PowerDVD Mark II update in the next few days.
– To download the free trial version of CyberLink PowerDVD 10 Ultra version of the player…
Tags:3d update·3d vision·arcsoft·blu-ray 3d·Mark-II Update·powerdvd 10·powerdvd 10 ultra·Sim3D Plugin·stereo 3d·TotalMedia Theatre 3 Platinum
It seems that ArcSoft has managed to beat the competition by actually being the first company that offers Blu-ray 3D support for its premiere product for playing back movies and videos – ArcSoft TotalMedia Theatre 3 Platinum. The company has released a 3D Plug-In for TotalMedia Theatre 3 Platinum called Sim3D that supposedly adds Blu-ray 3D Movie decoding capabilities as well as stereo 3D video playback and 2D to 3D photo and video conversion features. You need to have the TotalMedia Theatre 3 Platinum already installed (priced at $89.99 USD) and then get the Sim3D Plugin and install it (another $19.99 USD) to make everything work so the total cost for this solution if you don’t already have the TMT3 Platinum software goes to $109,98 USD which is quite expensive, but if you already have the main software the plugin comes quite cheap.
The Sim3D plugin does support Blu-ray 3D playback, 2D to 3D conversion for DVD Video and video clips as well as 2D photos and stereo 3D video files playback if they are in Side by Side or Over/Under format. You should however note that Sim3D currently does not support 2D to 3D conversion form 2D Blu-ray movies, although you can probably find a workaround over this by using software such as AnyDVD HD.
The 3D displays modes supported by the Sim3D plugin are anaglyph red-cyan 3D on a normal displays, PageFlip mode for 120Hz LCD displays including 3D Vision support, Line Interleaved mode for display using passive polarization and Checkerboard mode for 3D DLP TVs. No word on support for the new wave of HDMI 1.4(a)-based 3D HDTVs, but this may come as well with a later updates as otherwise you’ll have to use external hardware Blu-ray 3D player to play the movies on such a new 3D HDTV.
– For more details about ArcSoft’s Sim3D Plugin for TMT 3 Platinum…
Tags:120hz lcd·2d to 3d conversion·3d vision·anaglyph 3d·arcsoft·blu-ray 3d·blu-ray 3d movies·Blu-ray 3D Support Plugin·Sim3D·Sim3D Plugin·stereo 3d·TotalMedia Theatre 3 Platinum